Pay for Katrina: No more Bush tax
cuts
Twin Cities.com
BILL PRESS
TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES
September 25, 2005
In the darkest days of the American Revolution, Thomas Paine wrote: "These
are the times that try men's souls." In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, to
which must now be added the costs of Hurricane Rita, he could well write:
"These are the times that try men's wallets."
There is no question of America's resolve. We witnessed the destruction. We
see the need. We know what has to be done. We are determined to rebuild the
Gulf Coast and the great city of New Orleans. We will do what is necessary,
stay as long as it takes and pay any price.
The $64,000 question is: How are we going to pay for it? And with Katrina
alone, that's a big ticket. Congress has already shelled out $62 billion.
That's just for starters. The total reconstruction tag will easily surpass $200
billion. And this, of course, is in addition to: more than $200 billion for the
war in Iraq; a $700 billion Medicare prescription drug program; a bloated $268
billion highway bill; $105 billion for NASA's new shot at the moon. And it's on
top of an existing $330 billion budget deficit.
As the legendary Sen. Everett Dirksen might say, adjusting his original
numbers for inflation: "A hundred billion here, a hundred billion there, and
pretty soon we're talking real money." At some point, even the seemingly
bottomless federal money well runs dry. Looking to pay for Katrina, there are
four options: cutting spending, adding to the deficit, suspending the new
Medicare prescription drug benefit, or freezing the new Bush tax cuts for the
rich. Only one of them makes sense.
In a rare departure from conservative orthodoxy, House Majority Leader Tom
Delay recently declared that spending cuts were impossible because there was
"simply no fat left in the budget." Clearly, he forgot about all the pork in
the highway bill, like the $50 million indoor rainforest in Iowa, or Alaska's
$300 million bridge to an island with only 50 inhabitants. Still, budget cuts
alone will not pay for Katrina. On to bigger pots of dough.
Borrowing more money by adding to the federal debt is the easy way out - and
the most irresponsible. We've already saddled our children and grandchildren
with an $8 trillion national debt. It would be unfair to stick them with still
more debt. Unfair and dangerous. Foreigners now own $2.3 trillion of U.S.
government debt, meaning that every American man, woman and child owes foreign
investors $6,846. Sell any more debt overseas and we will soon be little more
than a major subsidiary of Japan or China.
That narrows it down to two real options: cutting Medicare or cutting the
Bush tax cuts. And there is no doubt which is the better policy. Seeing the
human suffering in Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama, only the
cold-hearted would say: I refuse to cancel or delay another tax cut for the
rich. I'd rather steal prescription drugs from needy seniors.
Asked if he's willing to put his tax cuts on the table, President Bush
sounds like a broken record: "We're not going to raise taxes." Who does he
think he's kidding? No matter how many times he says it, or no matter how often
you hear it on Fox News, nobody's talking about raising taxes. What some
members of Congress, Republicans and Democrats, have proposed is rolling back
those Bush tax cuts for the rich that have not yet kicked in.
According to the nonpartisan Citizens for Tax Justice, suspending income-tax
cuts that benefit only the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans would yield $336
billion between 2006 and 2010; leaving the estate tax in place would yield
another $80 billion. These combined are more than enough to bring back the
whole Gulf Coast. Without raising taxes.
Maybe the Bush tax cuts made sense at one time, when we enjoyed a huge,
Clinton-era surplus. But no longer. There's now a crying public need, and a far
greater public good.
In the recovery efforts along the Gulf, there have been reports of many
miracles. Now we can only pray for one more - the miracle that even George W.
Bush will wake up one morning and say: Helping people and communities rebuild
their lives is more important than rewarding my fat-cat friends with one more
tax cut.
But don't hold your breath.
Bill Press writes for Tribune Media Services.
|