|
Hannity falsely claimed Reagan tax cuts
"doubled revenues"
Media Matters
September 16, 2005
On the September 15 edition of Fox News' Hannity & Colmes, co-host Sean
Hannity falsely asserted that President Reagan's 1981 tax cuts "doubled
revenues ... from $500 billion to over $1 trillion." In fact, when adjusted for
inflation, revenue growth during Reagan's eight years in office was far more
modest than Hannity proclaimed. Moreover, there is no consensus among
economists on whether the 1981 tax cuts were the cause of revenue increases
during the Reagan years.
According to the White House's Office of Management and Budget (OMB), when
adjusted for inflation to constant fiscal year 2000 dollars, receipts
(revenues) increased only from $1.077 trillion to $1.236 trillion during
Reagan's term in office. Even in unadjusted (current) dollars, Hannity's claim
that revenues "doubled" to more than $1 trillion during the Reagan
administration is false: From 1981 to 1988, revenues in current dollars
increased from $599.3 billion to $909.3 billion.
From OMB:
FISCAL YEAR
|
REVENUE IN CURRENT DOLLARS (billions)
|
REVENUE IN CONSTANT FY2000 DOLLARS
(billions)
|
1981
|
599.3
|
1,077.4
|
1982
|
617.8
|
1,036.9
|
1983
|
600.6
|
961.7
|
1984
|
666.5
|
1,016.8
|
1985
|
734.1
|
1,082.6
|
1986
|
769.2
|
1,107.3
|
1987
|
854.4
|
1,196.1
|
1988
|
909.3
|
1,235.6
|
Further, evidence suggests that the Reagan tax cuts were not the cause of
the revenue increases that did occur during the 1980s. As the Center on Budget
and Policy Priorities (CBPP) has documented, citing figures from OMB, "Income
tax receipts grew noticeably more slowly than usual in the 1980s, after the
large cuts in individual and corporate income tax rates in 1981." By contrast,
"income tax collections grew much more rapidly in the 1990s," when "marginal
income tax rates at the top of the income spectrum were raised," CBPP
noted.
From a September 15 Hannity & Colmes discussion of President Bush's
speech on Hurricane Katrina relief efforts:
HANNITY: What I liked about what the president did tonight is,
we're going to help, but we're going to help the right way -- a Gulf
Opportunity Zone, Enterprise Zone, tax breaks. The private sector, the public
sector joining together and doing the right thing. That is conservatism --
compassionate conservatism.
ALAN COLMES (co-host): But when you talk about tax breaks, though,
how do you pay for it? He's got to address at some point how do we pay for
these billions and billions of dollars? Do you do it with tax
cuts?
HANNITY: Everybody -- well, tax breaks actually increase revenues
to the government. Reagan doubled revenues by cutting taxes, from $500 billion
to over a trillion, and he did it in eight years.
COLMES: Biggest deficits in history up until now with
Reagan.
HANNITY: No. He doubled revenues to government. More money came in
than ever before.
|
|