CIA rebukes Bush: intelligence predicted
war would split Iraq
CIA review faults prewar plans
USA Today
John Diamond, USA TODAY
October 12, 2005
WASHINGTON — A newly released report published by the CIA rebukes the
Bush administration for not paying enough attention to prewar intelligence that
predicted the factional rivalries now threatening to split Iraq.
Policymakers worried more about making the case for the war, particularly
the claim that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, than planning for the
aftermath, the report says. The report was written by a team of four former CIA
analysts led by former deputy CIA director Richard Kerr.
"In an ironic twist, the policy community was receptive to technical
intelligence (the weapons program), where the analysis was wrong, but
apparently paid little attention to intelligence on cultural and political
issues (post-Saddam Iraq), where the analysis was right," they write.
White House spokesman Fred Jones said Tuesday that the administration
considered many scenarios involving postwar instability in Iraq. The report's
assertion "has been vehemently disputed," he said.
Then-CIA director George Tenet commissioned the report after the invasion of
Iraq. The authors had access to highly classified intelligence data and
produced three reports concerning Iraq intelligence.
Only the third has been released in declassified form. It is published in
the current issue of Studies in Intelligence, a CIA quarterly written primarily
for intelligence professionals. The report was finished in July 2004 just as
Tenet was ending his tenure as CIA director.
The report determined that beyond the errors in assessing Iraqi weaponry,
"intelligence produced prior to the war on a wide range of other issues
accurately addressed such topics as how the war would develop and how Iraqi
forces would or would not fight."
The intelligence "also provided perceptive analysis on Iraq's links to
al-Qaeda; calculated the impact of the war on oil markets; and accurately
forecast the reactions of ethnic and tribal factions in Iraq."
The postwar struggle pitting Sunni Arabs against Shiite and Kurdish factions
has led some analysts, including Saud al-Faisal, foreign minister of
neighboring Saudi Arabia, to conclude Iraq is at risk of splitting into three
pieces.
Kerr's report agrees with other government reviews in concluding that prewar
intelligence on Iraqi weapons was faulty. Costly U.S. spy satellites were of
little help, providing "accurate information on relatively few critical
issues."
Intelligence analysts, the report says, failed to question their assumptions
that Iraq had maintained chemical and biological weapons and had reactivated
nuclear weapons development. Doubts about the intelligence received little
attention, "hastening the conversion of heavily qualified judgments into
accepted fact."
|