Bush names his legal 'pit bull' as next
Supreme Court nominee
Times Online
By Mark Sellman and agencies
October 03, 2005
President Bush has nominated his former personal lawyer and the White House
counsel to fill the Supreme Court vacancy left by the retirement of Sandra Day
O'Connor, eschewing tradition by selecting a non-judge.
Harriet Miers, 60, who has been a close ally of the President since his days
as Governor of Texas and whom he once described as a "pit bull in size 6
shoes", would be the third woman ever to serve on the Supreme Court if her
nomination is approved by the Senate.
Mrs O'Connor was a key swing vote on the closely divided Supreme Court
and her replacement will undergo more scrutiny intense scrutiny than the
nominee for Chief Justice, John Roberts, who was confirmed last week.
In fact, Mrs Miers's nomination received a generally favourable response
from Democrats and Senate Republicans. But she was derided by conservative
groups as a "stealth nominee" who could betray them on social issues like
abortion and gay rights.
One group, Public Advocate, said the nomination was a "betrayal of the
conservative, pro-family voters whose support put Bush in the White House in
both the 2000 and 2004 elections£.
In an Oval Office ceremony with Ms Miers at his side, Mr Bush credited her
with breaking down barriers to women in the Texas legal profession, becoming
the first woman to head her Dallas law firm, the first woman president of the
Dallas Bar Association and the first woman elected president of the state bar
of Texas.
"I believe that senators of both parties will find that Harriet
Miers's talent, experience and judicial philosophy make her a superb
choice to safeguard the constitutional liberties and quality of all Americans,"
he said.
The President called on the Senate to conduct her confirmation hearings with
"the same respect and civility" granted to Justice Roberts.
He said that Ms Miers would not legislate from the bench, one of his
requirements for judicial nominees "I ask the Senate to review her
qualifications thoroughly and fairly and to vote on her nomination promptly,"
he said.
Ms Miers said that she looked forward to the confirmation process. "If
confirmed I recognise that I will have a tremendous responsibility to keep our
judicial system strong and to help ensure that the courts meet their
obligations to strictly apply the laws in the Constitution," she said.
A senior administration official said that Ms Miers's name came up in
consultations with both Republican and Democratic senators as someone who could
win bipartisan support.
The official also said some senators from both parties thought it was
important for Mr Bush to pick someone who was not a judge and could offer a
different perspective on the job. The President offered her the job on Sunday
night over dinner at the White House, the official said.
Ms Miers has represented Mr Bush personally and as a candidate for governor
and president. In Austin, when he was Governor, Mr Bush appointed her to head
the Texas Lottery Commission.
Legal experts have said that if Mr Bush chose someone without a judicial
record, the White House should be prepared for the nominee to be peppered with
questions, as there would be less for senators and the public to go on when
looking at such a nominee's judicial philosophy.
Jerry Clements, a former colleague who heads the litigation section for the
Dallas law firm of Locke, Liddell & Sapp, had previously described Ms Miers
as an independent character.
"Harriet Miers is not a 'yes' person," Ms Clements added. "She has the
character and the capabilities to say 'no' if she thinks 'no' is the right
answer."
|