55% in Survey Say Libby Case Signals
Broader Problems
The Washington Post
By Richard Morin and Claudia Deane
Washington Post Staff Writers
Sunday, October 30, 2005; Page A14
A majority of Americans say the indictment of senior White House aide I.
Lewis "Scooter" Libby signals broader ethical problems in the Bush
administration, and nearly half say the overall level of honesty and ethics in
the federal government has fallen since President Bush took office, according
to a new Washington Post-ABC News survey.
The poll, conducted Friday night and yesterday, found that 55 percent of the
public believes the Libby case indicates wider problems "with ethical
wrongdoing" in the White House, while 41 percent believes it was an "isolated
incident." And by a 3 to 1 ratio, 46 percent to 15 percent, Americans say the
level of honesty and ethics in the government has declined rather than risen
under Bush.
In the aftermath of the latest crisis to confront the White House, Bush's
overall job approval rating has fallen to 39 percent, the lowest of his
presidency in Post-ABC polls. Barely a third of Americans -- 34 percent --
think Bush is doing a good job ensuring high ethics in government, which is
slightly lower than President Bill Clinton's standing on this issue when he
left office.
The survey also found that nearly seven in 10 Americans consider the charges
against Libby to be serious. A majority -- 55 percent -- said the decision of
Special Counsel Patrick J. Fitzgerald to bring charges against Libby was based
on the facts of the case, while 30 percent said he was motivated by partisan
politics.
"One thing you can't ever, ever do even if you're a regular person is lie to
a grand jury," said Brad Morris, 48, a registered independent and a field
representative for a lumber company who lives in Nashua, N.H. "But multiply
that by a thousand times if you have power like [Libby had]. And if anybody
wants to know why, ask Scooter. He's financially ruined; he'll be paying
lawyers for the rest of his life."
Taken together, the findings represent a serious blow to a White House
already reeling from the politically damaging effects of the slow government
response to Hurricane Katrina, the continuing bloodshed in Iraq, the ongoing
criticism of its since-repudiated claims that Iraq possessed weapons of mass
destruction and the bungled nomination of Harriet Miers to the Supreme
Court.
The ethics findings may be particularly upsetting to a president who came to
office in 2000 vowing to restore integrity and honor to a White House that he
said had been tainted by the recurring scandals of the Clinton years.
On Friday, a federal grand jury in Washington indicted Libby, Vice President
Cheney's chief of staff, on two counts of making false statements, two counts
of perjury and one count of obstruction of justice in the course of
Fitzgerald's investigation into the disclosure of the name of covert CIA
operative Valerie Plame to reporters. Plame's husband, former ambassador Joseph
C. Wilson IV, has accused the Bush administration of going to war in Iraq based
on intelligence officials knew was untrue.
The survey of 600 randomly selected Americans represents a snapshot of
initial reactions to the Libby indictment. Those views could quickly change as
the public learns more about the charges and as Republicans and Democrats mount
competing campaigns to shape public attitudes. The margin of sampling error for
the overall results is plus or minus four percentage points.
Those campaigns may play an influential role in the public's final
conclusions about the leak investigation. In the 24 hours after Fitzgerald's
news conference, the survey and follow-up interviews found many Americans
confused as to what, if anything, to make of the complicated indictment.
Ellen Mulligan, 34, a Republican and part-time art teacher who lives in
Hamden, Conn., was one of these. "If I understood what happened, Vice President
Cheney's adviser spoke to his wife and then she leaked the secret," Mulligan
said.
That is not an allegation in the indictment, but though Mulligan may not
know exactly what happened, the scandal for her is both typical Washington and
part of a broader pattern of ethical challenges in this administration. "My
actual opinion is more, 'Here we go again.' Every administration has their
secrets and has some corruption," she said. But she is disappointed with Bush
on the ethics front. "I think Bush's actions in certain situations are pretty
much unethical, [though] not illegal. . . . He's definitely not his father. His
father seemed more wholesome, more down-to-earth."
The survey found some areas of general agreement. Most Republicans, 57
percent, said that the obstruction of justice and perjury charges are serious,
compared with 81 percent of Democrats and 68 percent of independents.
But once past the specifics of the charges against Libby, Republicans and
Democrats differed dramatically. While a large majority of Democrats (76
percent) said the case is a sign of broader ethical problems in the
administration, an equally large majority of Republicans (69 percent) said it
was an isolated matter. Most Republicans continued to give Bush high marks for
his handling of ethics in government, while Democrats overwhelmingly graded him
poorly.
The survey also suggests the emergence of an appealing fresh face in public
life: special prosecutor Fitzgerald. Fifty-five percent said Fitzgerald brought
the charges against Libby based on the facts of the case and not for partisan
political reasons. Less than a third -- 30 percent -- said Fitzgerald was
politically motivated.
"I was very impressed by him," said Dorothy Harper, 56, an immigration
lawyer and a St. Louis Democrat, who watched portions of Fitzgerald's news
conference. "He was very impressive. He obviously knew what he was doing."
Many Americans believe that others may be involved in the disclosure of
Plame's identity to the news media. Nearly half -- 47 percent -- believe that
senior White House adviser Karl Rove did something wrong in connection with the
case, including nearly a fifth who believe that Rove acted illegally.
On Friday, Rove was not indicted, though Fitzgerald's investigation is
continuing.
A smaller but still significant proportion -- 41 percent -- believe Cheney
did something wrong, while 44 percent believe he did not.
Most Americans believe Bush had nothing to do with the incidents that
resulted in the indictment brought against Libby: 55 percent said the president
was not at fault, while 12 percent said he probably did something illegal, and
21 percent said he did something "unethical but not illegal."
|