White House Lies about Pull Out
Plan
Yahoo News/AFP
White House lays foundation for US troop withdrawal
November 27, 2005
WASHINGTON (AFP) - The White House for the first time has claimed possession
of an Iraq withdrawal plan, arguing that a troop pullout blueprint unveiled
this past week by a Democratic senator was "remarkably similar" to its own.
It also signaled its acceptance of a recent US Senate amendment designed to
pave the way for a phased US military withdrawal from the violence-torn
country.
The statement late Saturday by White House spokesman Scott McClellan came in
response to a commentary published in The Washington Post by Joseph Biden, the
top Democrat of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, in which he said US
forces will begin leaving Iraq next year "in large numbers."
According to Biden, the United States will move about 50,000 servicemen out
of the country by the end of 2006, and "a significant number" of the remaining
100,000 the year after.
The blueprint also calls for leaving only an unspecified "small force"
either in Iraq or across the border to strike at concentrations of insurgents,
if necessary.
In the White House statement, which was released under the headline "Senator
Biden Adopts Key Portions Of Administration's Plan For Victory In Iraq,"
McClellan said the administration of President George W. Bush welcomed Biden's
voice in the debate.
"Today, Senator Biden described a plan remarkably similar to the
administration's plan to fight and win the war on terror," the spokesman went
on to say.
McClellan added that as Iraqi security forces gain strength and experience,
"we can lessen our troop presence in the country without losing our capability
to effectively defeat the terrorists."
McClellan said the White House now saw "a strong consensus" building in
Washington in favor of Bush's strategy in Iraq.
Speaking on US television Sunday, Biden said that with or without a
near-term troop withdrawal, the window is rapidly closing on the opportunity
for a US success in Iraq.
"I think we have a six-month window here to get it right," he said.
Even if conditions on the ground there improve, "I have to admit that I
think the chances are not a lot better than 50-50," the Democratic lawmaker
said.
"Are we going to have traded a dictator for chaos? Or are we going to have
traded a dictator for a stable Iraq? That's the real question. And that depends
on the president's actions from here out," said Biden.
Less than two weeks ago, McClellan blasted Democratic Representative John
Murtha (news, bio, voting record) for calling for an immediate withdrawal from
Iraq.
McClelland accused Murtha of "endorsing the policy positions of Michael
Moore," a stridently anti-war Hollywood filmmaker.
Biden's ideas, relayed first in a November 21 speech in New York, however,
got a much friendlier reception.
Even though Bush has never publicly issued his own withdrawal plan and
criticized calls for an early exit, the White House said many of the ideas
expressed by the senator were its own.
The Biden plan calls for preparatory work to be done in the first six months
of next year, ahead of the envisaged pullout. It includes:
- forging a compromise among Iraqi factions, under which the Sunnis must
accept that they no longer rule Iraq and Shiites and Kurds admit them into a
power-sharing arrangement;
- building Iraq's governing capacity;
- transferring authority to Iraqi security forces;
- establishing a contact group of the world's major powers to become the
Iraqi government's primary international interlocutor.
The White House statement also embraced a Senate amendment to a defense
authorization bill overwhelmingly passed by the Senate on November 15 that
asked the administration to make next year "a period of significant transition
to full Iraqi sovereignty" thereby creating conditions "for the phased
redeployment of United States forces from Iraq."
The measure was largely seen as a reprimand to the Bush administration,
which has often been accused of lacking a viable strategy in Iraq.
But the White House insisted again the Senate was reading from its own
playbook.
"The fact is that the Senate amendment reiterates the president's strategy
in Iraq," the statement said.
|