Lott Suggests Prison Leak Came from
GOP
Probe Sought in Leak About CIA-Run Secret Prisons
LA Times
November 8, 2005
WASHINGTON -- With pressure mounting on the administration over its detainee
policies, Republican House and Senate leaders today sought a Congressional
probe into who leaked information on the existence of CIA-run secret prisons
abroad to the Washington Post.
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.) and House Speaker J. Dennis
Hastert (R-Ill.) circulated a letter asking the intelligence committees to
"immediately initiate a joint investigation into the possible release of
classified information to the media," about the existence of the prisons.
"As you know, if accurate, such an egregious disclosure could have long-term
and far-reaching damaging and dangerous consequences," the pair said in their
letter to Rep. Peter Hoekstra (R-Mich.), chairman of the House Intelligence
Committee, and Sen. Pat Roberts (R-Kan.), chairman of the Senate Intelligence
Committee.
The request came as Democrats continued to demand an independent inquiry
into allegations of detainee abuse and into the administration's handling of
pre-war intelligence, and Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) continued his fight to
issue clear instructions to U.S. military and intelligence personnel banning
cruel and inhumane treatment of prisoners.
The Senate has passed a McCain-sponsored amendment barring torture of
detainees and setting standards for their treatment. The administration opposes
the restrictions and has threatened to veto the $440 billion defense bill to
which it is attached. The House has not voted on the measure.
Responding to news of the request by congressional leaders for a probe into
the source of the Post's information, White House press secretary Scott
McClellan said it was a serious matter.
"It ought to be taken seriously," McClellan said. "But this is a
congressional prerogative and it was a decision that was made by those leaders
and that's the way I would describe it."
On Nov. 2, the Post revealed the existence of a network of clandestine
prisons in Eastern Europe where it said the CIA was holding suspected
terrorists. The administration has neither confirmed nor denied the report, but
its publication intensified the debate on Capitol Hill about the
administration's detainee policies.
Late this afternoon, a senior Republican aide on the Senate Intelligence
Committee said the panel had not yet received Frist's and Hastert's letter. The
aide, who requested anonymity because of the political sensitivity of the
issue, said he could not recall an instance in which the committee investigated
an alleged leak of classified information, except when there was suspicion that
someone on the panel's staff had been involved.
"We will work with the leadership," if Frist's office wants a congressional
probe, the aide said. But he cautioned that leak investigations ordinarily were
carried out by the Justice Department, and that the committee generally avoided
encroaching on criminal probes.
"If the Justice Dept. gets engaged, it becomes very problematic to cross
paths with them," the aide said.
Democratic congressional leaders welcomed the call for an investigation, but
said it should be broader than the possible leak of classified information
about the prison system.
In a statement, Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said that
"leaking is unacceptable." But, he said, "while Republicans have been quick to
call for an investigation of this matter, they have repeatedly and regularly
resisted any real oversight of this administration's flawed policies."
The minority leader said he hoped the majority's "newfound zeal for
investigations," will mean they will also push for a probe into "how this
administration used and misused intelligence as it made its case for war in
Iraq."
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-San Francisco) said that "if Speaker
Hastert and Majority Leader Frist are finally ready to join Democrats' demands
for an investigation of possible abuses of classified information, they must
direct the House and Senate Intelligence Committee to investigate all aspects
of that issue."
At least one Senate Republican agreed.
Asked whether he believed there should be a probe of the possible leaking of
classified information on the existence of the prisons, or of the existence of
the prisons themselves, Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, a former
military lawyer, rolled his eyes and replied: "How about both? I'd like to know
why we've got secret prisons and what oversight precautions we have."
Graham said it was "imperative we regain the moral high ground and having
secret prisons come out in the Washington Post is not a good way to regain
it."
Another Republican, Sen. Trent Lott of Mississippi, said it may have been
Republican senators who leaked the information to the Post. Lott told reporters
that the existence of the secret prison system was discussed last week during
the Republican policy luncheon, held on Capitol Hill the day before the Post
story appeared.
"Information that was said in there, given out in there, did get into the
newspaper," Lott said.
Asked whether he believed it was Republicans who had breached security, Lott
said: "I don't know where else it came from...it looked to me that at least one
of those reports came right out of that room."
In their letter, Frist and Hastert said the committees should determine
whether the information given to the Post was accurate, who leaked it and "what
is the actual and potential damage done to the national security of the United
States and our partners in the global war on terror."
The leaders said they would "consider other changes to this mandate based on
your recommendations." They said that "the leaking of classified information by
employees of the United States government appears to have increased in recent
years, establishing a dangerous trend that, if not addressed swiftly and
firmly, likely will worsen."
Earlier this month, I. Lewis Libby, Vice President Dick Cheney's chief of
staff, was indicted on five counts of perjury, obstruction of justice and
giving false statements in connection with the leak to reporters of the name of
a CIA operative, Valerie Plame. Libby, who has since resigned, has pleaded not
guilty to those charges.
|