List shows some of Bush's claims on Iraq
haven't held up
Knox News/Scripps Howard News Service
BILL STRAUB,
November 27, 2005
WASHINGTON - President Bush is engaged in a bitter exchange with critics who
maintain the White House intentionally misled the public to generate support
for the war in Iraq.
Evidently most people seem to believe those claims - 64 percent of those
questioned in the most recent Harris Interactive Poll believe the
administration "generally misleads the public on current issues."
The administration has acknowledged that the intelligence used to advance
the argument that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction was faulty. But
critics say their claims that Bush is providing misleading data is based on
other declarations:
- On Oct. 7, 2002, during a speech in Cincinnati, the president said Iraq
was involved in training al-Qaeda members. It subsequently was learned through
Defense Intelligence Agency documents that the sole source for that claim, Ibn
al-Shaykh al-Libi, a top al-Qaeda operative, "was intentionally misleading the
debriefers" when he offered that information. That report was issued in
February 2002 - before Bush included the allegation in his speech.
- In that same presentation, the president said Iraq maintained a "growing
fleet of manned and unmanned aerial vehicles" that could be used in missions
targeting the United States. But the U.S. Air Force, in a National Intelligence
Estimate released to the White House just before Bush's appearance, declared
that Iraq was developing the UAVs "primarily for reconnaissance rather than
delivery platforms."
- In his Jan. 28, 2003, State of the Union address, Bush cited intelligence
sources when he declared Iraq "attempted to purchase high-strength aluminum
tubes suitable for nuclear weapons." Three months earlier, the Office of
Intelligence within the Department of Energy determined that the aluminum tubes
were not intended for Iraq's nuclear program.
- Vice President Cheney, during a Dec. 9, 2001, appearance on NBC's "Meet
the Press," said it was "pretty well confirmed" that Mohammed Atta, the
ring-leader of the 9/11 hijackers, met with Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani,
an Iraqi government official, in Prague, Czech Republic, on April 8, 2001,
providing evidence of a link between the terrorist group and the Iraqi
government. Neither the CIA nor the FBI believes Atta left the United States
that April.
Then there is the part of the 2003 State of the Union address where Bush
noted the British government "has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought
significant quantities of uranium from Africa." Before the speech, the CIA
warned the administration that the claim shouldn't be cited because it could
not be confirmed. The State Department, in the October 2002 National
Intelligence Estimate, declared that the uranium claim was "highly
dubious."
|