Republicans' Disarray Yields Budget
Setbacks
WSJ Online
By DAVID ROGERS and BRODY MULLINS
Staff Reporters of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
November 11, 2005; Page A6
WASHINGTON -- Plagued by internal divisions, Republicans stumbled badly on
two budget fronts as the House postponed action on a major deficit-reduction
bill and the Senate Finance Committee couldn't summon a majority for promised
tax-cut extensions.
Republican leaders insisted that the setbacks were temporary. But the level
of disarray was striking, and the delays throw a monkey wrench into plans to
wrap up this session of Congress.
The Finance panel has rescheduled a meeting Monday and is leaning toward
shelving plans to extend President Bush's 15% rates for capital gains and
dividends, set to expire at the end of 2008. House Ways and Means Committee
Chairman Bill Thomas will mark up his version of the tax cuts Tuesday,
including the extension of the lower rates. But getting House floor time will
be hard until the deficit-reduction debate is resolved, and the California
Republican's tax bill doesn't provide any relief for middle-income families
threatened by the alternative-minimum tax.
Most clear are the growing divisions between Republican moderates and
conservatives as Mr. Bush's standing in the polls has fallen and more tensions
have surfaced over the deficit and the party's fiscal agenda.
The troubles in the House are more remarkable because it has been an engine
for the Republican agenda. The leadership is clearly strained since former
Majority Leader Tom DeLay (R., Texas) stepped down after his indictment for
alleged campaign-finance violations. Still, he hovers over the shoulder of his
successor, Rep. Roy Blunt (R., Mo.), and conservative committee chairmen close
to Mr. DeLay have been more rebellious as Mr. Blunt tries to thread his way
through the problems.
The rivalry between the conservative Republican Study Committee, which wants
spending and tax cuts, and the moderates' Tuesday Group is open and sometimes
raw. Moderates speak derisively of the RSC as the "College Republicans." With a
smile, Rep. Michael Castle (R., Del.) told a reporter this week, "You have to
understand, the RSC not only doesn't like to lose, they don't like us to
win."
Budget debates are always partisan fights, but the lines are also more
sharply drawn this year because of economic troubles in farm states, where
rural moderate Democrats once might have been willing to cross the aisle.
Instead, with farmers facing low commodity prices and high energy costs, these
lawmakers are as opposed to spending and tax cuts this year as more liberal
urban Democrats.
Much of the government is still operating under a stopgap funding bill that
expires Nov. 18, and on this Veterans Day weekend, Congress has approved
neither the defense budget nor new money for veterans medical care for the
fiscal year that began Oct. 1.
The one bright spot -- and show of unity last night -- was a $21 billion
foreign-aid bill passed and sent to the White House, reflecting an historic
commitment to fighting disease overseas. Funding to battle AIDS, malaria, and
tuberculosis rose to $2.82 billion, and altogether about $3.4 billion is
devoted to health-related programs.
By comparison, the $50 billion-plus deficit-reduction bill, pulled from the
House floor, has upset moderates, who worry that too much is being taken from
the working poor when Republicans are extending tax cuts, such as those for
capital gains that favor higher income households.
Late Wednesday, Republicans had hoped to buy peace by removing a plan to
open up portions of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil and gas
exploration. But as swing members were brought in to talk with Speaker Dennis
Hastert (R., Ill.), the House remained in recess for most of yesterday.
As more lawmakers left for the weekend, the leadership found it was only
falling further behind. "We weren't quite ready to go to the floor," Mr. Blunt
said after pulling the bill.
In the Senate Finance Committee, it took only one moderate, Sen. Olympia
Snowe (R., Maine), to frustrate Chairman Charles Grassley (R., Iowa), who needs
all 11 of the panel's Republicans to support his bill.
To get Ms. Snowe's vote, Mr. Grassley had proposed just a one-year extension
of the 15% capital-gains and dividend rates. Now it seems more likely he will
jettison the investor tax breaks entirely and assume they can be restored when
the final tax package is negotiated with the House.
Ms. Snowe, who faces re-election next year in a state that Mr. Bush lost in
2004, said she has become increasingly concerned about the government's
deficits, which are aggravated by the costs of wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and
rebuilding the Gulf Coast after the recent devastating hurricanes. Extending
tax cuts that don't expire until 2008, she said, should take second
priority.
"In the end it is going to get done," said Sen. Gordon Smith (R., Oregon),
but he himself helped blocked the same sort of Medicaid savings that have
aggravated moderates in the House. "It's a lot easier to get people to eat
candy than spinach," said Rep. Tom Cole (R., Okla.), "And right now we are on
the spinach side of the plate."
Write to David Rogers at david.rogers@wsj.com and Brody Mullins at
brody.mullins@wsj.com
|