Post 9/11 Intelligence Leak Ends for GOP
Sen. Shelby
Yahoo News/AP
Committee Ends Leak Probe of Sen. Shelby
By JEFFREY McMURRAY, Associated Press Writer
November 14, 2005
WASHINGTON - The Senate Ethics Committee has ended its intelligence leak
investigation of Sen. Richard Shelby (news, bio, voting record), who was under
suspicion of giving the news media classified messages from the eve of the
Sept. 11 attacks.
In a letter obtained Sunday by The Associated Press, the panel's chairman
and vice chairman notify Shelby that it considers the case closed, but they
don't say whether they blame him for the information getting out.
Shelby, a Republican from Alabama, is a former chairman of the Intelligence
Committee and was the vice chairman at the time of the alleged leak.
"I have been confident that the committee would dismiss this matter, and I
was pleased to learn of their decision to do just that," Shelby said in a
statement Sunday.
At issue were two messages intercepted by the National Security Agency a day
before the Sept. 11 terror attacks. News accounts attributed to anonymous
sources said those messages contained the words "the match begins tomorrow" and
"tomorrow is zero day," but they were not translated from Arabic until Sept.
12.
Intelligence officials said disclosing the Sept. 10 interceptions was
harmful not because of their substance, but because the disclosure might have
tipped off terrorists that one of their channels of communication had been
compromised.
The Justice Department referred the case to the Ethics Committee in July
2004. The committee's chairman, George Voinovich, R-Ohio, and vice chairman,
Tim Johnson, D-S.D., signed the letter sent Friday to Shelby.
In the letter, Voinovich and Johnson tell Shelby that the Department of
Justice had provided evidence concerning his "conduct in connection with the
disclosure and concerning 'related conduct.'"
It didn't elaborate on what that evidence was or why no penalty against
Shelby would be sought.
"This committee hereby considers this matter to be closed," the senators
wrote. A separate letter sent by the committee informed Attorney General
Alberto Gonzales it was dropping the case.
The letter was first reported by the National Journal on its Internet site
Sunday.
The Washington Post reported in 2004 that Shelby leaked the information to
Fox News reporter Carl Cameron after a classified briefing to the Intelligence
Committee. Cameron said he talked with the FBI but denied identifying Shelby as
the leaker.
"The sum total of my interaction was to tell them that there was no
information they could get from Carl Cameron or Fox News and to refer them to
my lawyers," Cameron told the AP last year.
The Post cited sources as saying Shelby met with a CNN reporter after
talking with Cameron and that CNN broadcast the information about an hour
later. Cameron said he did not air the material that day until after it had
already been reported by CNN.
The Post and USA Today reported more extensively on the leaked messages the
following day.
More than a year ago, the Alabama Republican hired lawyer Gregory Craig, who
represented President Clinton at his impeachment trial, to defend him in the
leak probe.
|