U.S. Expands List of Lost
Missiles
The New York Times
By DOUGLAS JEHL and DAVID E. SANGER
Published: November 6, 2004
WASHINGTON, Nov. 5 - American intelligence agencies have
tripled their formal estimate of shoulder-fired surface-to-air
missile systems believed to be at large worldwide, since
determining that at least 4,000 of the weapons in Iraq's prewar
arsenals cannot be accounted for, government officials said
Friday.
A new government estimate says a total of 6,000 of the weapons
may be outside the control of any government, up from a previous
estimate of 2,000, American officials said.
The officials said they did not know whether missiles from
Iraq remain there or have been smuggled into other countries,
though a senior administration official said Friday that "there
is no evidence that they have left the country.''
It was unclear whether Iraqi military or intelligence
personnel removed the missile systems during the initial invasion
of Iraq or whether they disappeared from warehouses after major
combat ended.
Shoulder-fired missiles - which are small, lethal and easy to
use - are attractive weapons for terrorists. In recent months,
Western intelligence and law enforcement agencies have repeatedly
warned that Al Qaeda intends to use them to shoot down planes. In
2002, attackers who launched two small Russian-made SA-7 missiles
almost hit a commercial aircraft taking off from Mombasa, Kenya.
The new estimate of a larger number of the missile systems was
discussed at a classified Defense Intelligence Agency conference
in Alabama this week, the officials said. They declined to
discuss the methods by which the new estimate had been reached,
saying that it was classified.
American intelligence analysts have said in the past that
during Saddam Hussein's rule, Iraq stockpiled at least 5,000 of
these missile systems, and that fewer than a third had been
recovered. The shelf life of the missiles can vary, with battery
life depending on the conditions under which they are stored.
Secretary of State Colin L. Powell said last fall that "no
threat is more serious to aviation" than the shoulder-fired
missiles, which can be bought on the black market for as little
as $5,000, are about five feet long and weigh as little as 35
pounds. More than 40 aircraft have been struck by shoulder-fired
surface-to-air missiles since the 1970's, causing at least 24
crashes and more than 600 deaths worldwide, according to a State
Department estimate. In Iraq, the missiles have been used in more
than a dozen attacks on American planes and helicopters,
including those taking off and landing at Baghdad's international
airport.
In recent months, the number of successful missile attacks on
American aircraft and helicopters in Iraq has declined, but
American officials have said the reason has largely been the
precautionary measures taken by the United States military.
An unclassified study released in June 2004 by what is now the
Government Accountability Office cited "U.S. government
estimates" that a few thousand of the portable missiles were
"outside government controls.'' A separate study released in
November 2003 by the Congressional Research Service cited
counterterrorism experts in saying that as many as 4,000 to 5,000
shoulder-fired missiles might be available to Iraqi
insurgents.
The new estimate by American intelligence agencies was
described by government officials who had access to the
classified intelligence report. They said the tripling of the
number represented the first formal effort to determine how
unaccounted Iraqi stockpiles may have compounded the
surface-to-air missile threat. Only several hundred
shoulder-fired surface-to-air missiles from the Iraqi arsenals
have been turned in to American forces in a buyout program, the
government officials said.
A Defense Department official said Friday that more than one
million shoulder-fired surface-to-air missiles had been produced
since the weapons were first manufactured in the 1950's, with 20
countries producing more than 35 different types of weapons.
According to the accountability office study, 500,000 to 750,000
shoulder-fired surface-to-air missiles are still believed to be
in the worldwide inventory. Many of the older missiles are
militarily obsolete and have been destroyed.
Until the invasion of Iraq, many of the shoulder-fired weapons
believed to be outside government controls were those provided by
the United States and its allies to mujahedeen fighters in
Afghanistan to assist in their resistance against Soviet forces
during the 1980's. Those weapons included American-made Stinger
and British-made Blowpipe missiles, but by December 2002,
American-led forces in Afghanistan had captured more than 5,000
of the missiles from the Taliban and Al Qaeda, according to news
reports at the time.
The Defense Intelligence Agency conference on the worldwide
threat to civil aviation posed by these portable air defense
systems was held Wednesday and Thursday by the agency's Missile
and Space Intelligence Center, at Redstone Arsenal, in
Huntsville, Ala.
The range and accuracy of the weapons can vary widely by type,
with the Russian-made SA-16 regarded as the most lethal in Iraq's
prewar arsenal. It is not known how many of the missiles may have
been fired at American planes and helicopters during the invasion
in 2003.
In an effort to address the missile threat, the Department of
Homeland Security has asked government contractors to find a way
to protect passenger jets from small shoulder-fired missiles. The
technology has been installed on military planes for years, using
laser-jamming equipment and decoy flares to deflect the missiles,
and some contractors have determined that passenger planes could
be outfitted with antimissile technology relatively soon.
The State Department has also started an aggressive effort to
persuade other countries to join in an effort to limit the
availability and proliferation of the weapons. In July, the House
of Representatives passed a bill that calls on the president to
pursue even stronger measures, and directs the administration to
expedite approval of new antimissile technologies. The Senate has
not yet acted on the bill.
The new government estimate follows the disclosure late last
month that more than 300 tons of powerful explosives had
disappeared since early March 2003 from an Iraqi site previously
monitored by the International Atomic Energy Agency. Video images
that emerged after that report appears to suggest that at least
some of the explosive material disappeared after the fall of the
Iraqi government. Unlike those explosives, surface-to-air
missiles in Iraq were not sealed or monitored by weapons
inspectors before the war and may have been widely dispersed
among the Iraqi forces in the field.
|