GOP Cultivates Hate to Win
Election
Bloomberg
Rove, Bush Campaign Architect, Cultivated Christians
(Update3)
November 4, 2004
Nov. 4 (Bloomberg) -- Four months after the Sept. 11, 2001,
terrorist attacks, Karl Rove used a rare public speech to
disclose his re-election strategy for George W. Bush: hammering
home the theme that the president would make the country
safer.
Privately, Rove engineered a different plan: cultivating
church leaders who could help lure back to the voting booths the
4 million evangelical Christians who Rove believed had ditched
Bush in 2000 because he had a drunk-driving record.
``He wasn't going to let that happen again,'' says Scott Reed,
who was Republican Bob Dole's presidential campaign manager in
1996. ``Rove had an aggressive plan that started four years ago
to work with church leadership to organize and speak positively
about the Bush agenda. He recognized that social conservatives
were the key to the kingdom.''
Four years after Bush became the first person since 1888 to
win the presidency while losing the popular vote, Rove -- his
chief political strategist and a man the president yesterday
called the ``architect'' of his campaign -- secured a second
victory. And he did it largely by turning out evangelical
Christian voters.
`Moral Values' Rule
The 53-year-old political mastermind, who never graduated from
college, helped Bush defeat four-term Massachusetts Senator John
Kerry partly by shifting America's attention away from the
821,000 jobs lost in Bush's first term, the rise in oil prices to
a record $55.17 a barrel on Oct. 22, and the decline in leading
economic indicators for the fourth-straight month in
September.
Bush, 58, received at least 279 electoral votes, nine more
than needed for victory. He also won the popular vote, 51 percent
to 48 percent, receiving 3.5 million more votes than Kerry.
Exit polls of 13,531 voters nationwide showed that 22 percent
cited ``moral values'' as their top issue in the election,
according to CNN. That trumped the 20 percent who cited the
economy, the 19 percent who chose terrorism and 15 percent who
selected the Iraq war. And 79 percent of those citing moral
values voted for Bush, the exit polls showed.
"There's a new cultural dividing line and it's becoming
Republican,'' says Vin Weber, Midwest chairman of the Bush
campaign. "It started in the South and it's moving north. It's
happening in small towns, rural areas. These are lifestyle
issues, not economic issues."
`Cultural Differences'
"The old dividing line used to be income," says Weber, a
congressman from Minnesota from 1981-1993. It's now cultural
differences: family values, patriotism, church attendance, gun
ownership, national security, even being able to use snowmobiles
on federal lands, which environmentalists oppose, he says.
Rove also banked on voters having differences with Kerry,
especially evangelical Christians, who were the focus of his
speech in January 2002 to a Republican National Committee meeting
in Austin, Texas.
"These are middle class, blue-collar states," he said in an
interview on Sept. 27, previewing the strategy for the final
month of the campaign. "It's hard for him to make a connection to
people in those states on a one-to-one basis," Rove said of
Kerry. "In addition to being extremely liberal from
Massachusetts, he's sort of, you know, condescending,
elitist."
Richard Land, president of the Nashville, Tennessee-based
Southern Baptist Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, and
other religious leaders say they have preached the importance of
voting based on moral issues.
"I told my congregation that I'd rather have a president who
protects unborn babies than cuts my taxes 50 percent," Land
says.
Christians Know Bush
At the same time, church organizations worked to mobilize
voters. In Ohio, members of the Christian Coalition distributed
more than 5 million voter guides in at least 5,000 churches in
two weekends before the election opposing gay marriage and
activist judges.
The Washington-based Christian Coalition estimates that 30
million evangelical Christians nationwide voted on Tuesday.
That's out of what the group says are between 60 million and 80
million of them in the U.S.
"Christians know the president much more than they did four
years ago," says Roberta Combs, president of the coalition, which
claims to be the largest U.S. Christian grassroots organization,
with more than 2 million supporters. "He proved he was a man of
faith."
Bush says he isn't worried that religious influence in
politics would lead to a divided nation. "My answer to people is
I will be your president regardless of your faith, and I don't
expect you to agree with me, necessarily, on religion," Bush told
a White House press conference today. People who don't worship,
he said, are "just as patriotic as your neighbor."
Courting Catholics
The importance of moral values was underscored in Ohio on Nov.
2, when the state expanded its law banning gay marriage with a
broader constitutional amendment against civil unions. Bush led
Kerry 51.1 percent to 48.4 percent in the state, with 99 percent
of the precincts reporting.
Bush has also courted the Catholic vote. That included getting
an audience with Pope John Paul II in Rome in June and
incorporating a picture on his campaign Web site with a headline
"Catholics for Bush."
The U.S. has 63 million Catholics -- including Kerry. Those
who say they attend church each week voted 53 percent to 45
percent for Bush, exit polls showed.
In addition, U.S. bishops campaigned against Kerry by writing
letters to parishioners about his stance supporting women's right
to choose abortion.
`God's People' Spoke
At the non-denominational Columbus Christian Center in
Columbus, Ohio, where voter-registration events were held and
where pastor David Forbes urged his mostly African-American
congregation for weeks to support Bush, last night's prayer
service was celebratory.
"I want to thank you all for being obedient to our call from
the Lord to pray and to let our voice be heard," Forbes told
about 150 churchgoers by conference phone from Washington, where
he was speaking at a church event.
Forbes, a 40-year-old Brooklyn native who founded the church
14 years ago, served on a steering committee for the Bush-Cheney
campaign in Ohio.
"Based on the results of the election, you can see that God's
people somewhere spoke up," Forbes said, as members of the
congregation shouted, "Amen," and cheered their approval. "Kerry
trailed all night, and in the final analysis he just could not
catch up, and so we thank God for that."
Out of Mainstream
In the final days of the campaign in battleground states, Bush
hammered away at the moral convictions that he suggested
separated him from his Democratic challenger. He rallied against
everything from gay marriages to partial-birth abortion to
activist federal judges, as he stressed his intention to preserve
marriage as an institution between man and woman.
A "clear choice in this election is on the values that are
crucial for families," Bush said at a rally in Wilmington, Ohio,
on Nov. 1. "There is a mainstream in American politics," Bush
said, and Kerry "sits on the far left bank."
That was the message that Rove wanted driven home to
voters.
Rove, born in Denver on Christmas Day 1950, is the son of an
oil company geologist. His relationship with Bush goes back
decades.
While attending the University of Utah in the early 1970s he
met Lee Atwater, the South Carolinian who eventually became the
chief political adviser to Bush's father, George H.W. Bush, and
helped him become the 41st president.
`Bush's Brain'
Rove admired Atwater's take-no-prisoners attitude toward
politics, according to a 2003 best-selling book by James Moore
and Wayne Slater, "Bush's Brain."
Rove rose rapidly in the College Republicans, with Atwater's
help. He and a colleague, Bernie Robinson, traveled the country,
"instructing his young audiences on dirty tricks -- pranks," at
seminars, according to the book.
The Watergate Special Prosecutor's office interviewed Rove
after hearing reports about dirty tricks taught at the seminars,
"an allegation found to be unfounded and dropped," Rove said.
Robinson, now a Washington lobbyist, denied either had done
anything wrong. "Karl Rove never suggested any untoward approach
to anything," Robinson said in a September interview.
Rove landed a position as an aide to the senior Bush, who was
head of the Republican National Committee from 1973-1975, and in
the late 1970s he moved to Texas. Rove got to know the younger
Bush from working with his father during the 1980 presidential
campaign. Rove ran George W. Bush's 1994 campaign for Texas
governor, where he upset Democratic incumbent Ann Richards, and
has stuck with him since.
Gay Marriage
A key in this year's election model, which Rove developed with
campaign director Ken Mehlman, were 1.2 million volunteers. The
volunteers were recruited last year, tested to ensure that they
were committed, and assigned to knock on doors or work telephone
banks in swing states such as Ohio and Florida.
To stir up support in battleground states, Rove sought to
rally evangelicals, who he says kept the margins close four years
ago by not voting.
To do that, Bush emphasized issues such as a constitutional
ban on gay marriage as well as his $1.7 trillion in tax cuts and
leadership in the war against terrorism.
"Bush maintained the very formidable religious coalition and
then added a little bit to it in key states," including Ohio and
Florida, says Steve Waldman, who covers religion and politics for
Beliefnet.com. "Values and religion both played a huge role in
Bush's victory."
Bush says he became a born-again Christian after a bout with
alcohol, and that was key to connecting with the 25 percent of
Ohioans who regard themselves as evangelicals, Waldman says. Bush
tried to win over those voters in that state as well as in
Florida and Iowa, which claim about the same percentage of
evangelical voters.
"Evangelical and religious Christians gave him a huge base
from which to start -- he only had to branch out a little bit,"
says Waldman, a former political reporter for U.S. News &
World Report magazine.
"His faith is part of why he's viewed as a strong wartime
leader."
To contact the reporters on this story:
Holly Rosenkrantz in Washington at
hrosenkrantz@Bloomberg.net.
Roger Runningen in Washington at
rrunningen@Bloomberg.net.
To contact the editor responsible for this story:
Glenn Hall at ghall@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: November 4, 2004 16:15 EST
|