Suit Alleges Rumsfeld
Approved Torture
Reuters
Alan Elsner
Tue Mar 1, 2005 04:21 PM ET
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Two U.S. human rights groups sued
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld on Tuesday, saying he first
authorized and then failed to stop torture of prisoners in Iraq
and Afghanistan.
The American Civil Liberties Union and Human Rights First
filed suit in federal district court in Rumsfeld's home state of
Illinois on behalf of eight former detainees who said they were
severely tortured. All eight were subsequently released without
being charged.
"Secretary Rumsfeld bears direct and ultimate responsibility
for this descent into horror by personally authorizing unlawful
interrogation techniques and by abdicating his legal duty to stop
torture," said Lucas Guttentag, lead counsel in the case.
The Pentagon denied that it ever sanctioned or condoned the
abuse of detainees.
"There have been multiple investigations into the various
aspects of detainee abuse. None have concluded there was a policy
of abuse," the Defense Department said in a statement.
The ACLU filed similar complaints against three other senior
officers: Col. Thomas Pappas, Gen. Janis Karpinski and Lt. Gen.
Ricardo Sanchez on behalf of prisoners mistreated at Iraq's Abu
Ghraib prison.
The suit against Rumsfeld focuses on an order he signed on
Dec. 2, 2002 that authorized new interrogation techniques for
detainees in the "war on terror" being held at Guantanamo Bay in
Cuba. These included "stress positions," hooding, 20-hour
interrogations, removal of clothing, exploiting phobias,
prolonged isolation and sensory deprivation.
When evidence became overwhelming that prisoners were being
tortured, Rumsfeld turned a blind eye, the suit alleges.
"Secretary Rumsfeld knew full well that his orders were
causing torture and he knew that torture was occurring on a
widespread basis and he did not stop it," Guttentag said.
SEEKING DAMAGES
The plaintiffs want the court to declare Rumsfeld's actions
unconstitutional and a violation of U.S. and international law.
They are seeking monetary damages for their injuries and all
eight are willing to come to the United States to testify.
The plaintiffs -- four Afghan citizens and four Iraqis --
allege treatment that included beatings, being cut with knives,
sexual abuse and humiliation, being locked in coffin-like boxes,
being deprived of food and water and threatened with execution
and being hung upside down for hours.
Arkan Mohammed Ali, a 26-year-old Iraqi held for a year from
June 2003 to 2004, alleges that U.S. personnel twice beat him
unconscious, used a knife to repeatedly stab and slice his
forearm, burned and shocked him with a metal device, locked him
naked for several days in a small wooden box, urinated on him and
made death threats against him.
Mehboob Ahmad, a 35-year-old Afghan citizen held for five
months in 2003, said he was probed anally, hung upside down from
the ceiling by a chain and hung by his arms for extended
periods.
The mistreatment of prisoners became an international scandal
after the appearance last year of pictures showing sexual abuse
of men at Abu Ghraib. The Bush administration said only a handful
of low-ranking personnel were involved.
Dozens of other cases have been brought against soldiers for
abusing detainees elsewhere in Iraq and in Afghanistan but
efforts to charge senior officers and administration officials
have not proceeded very far.
An August 2004 report by a panel appointed by Rumsfeld stated
that he and other top Pentagon leaders contributed to an
environment in which prisoners suffered sadistic abuse at Abu
Ghraib.
© Reuters 2005. All Rights Reserved.
|