Sen. Biden Suggests Scrapping
Hearings
Yahoo News/AP
January 12, 2006
WASHINGTON - Supreme Court nominees are so mum about the major legal issues
at their Senate confirmation hearings that the hearings serve little purpose
and should probably be abandoned, Democratic Sen. Joe Biden said Thursday.
"The system's kind of broken," said Biden, a member of the Judiciary
Committee considering the nomination of Judge Samuel Alito.
"Nominees now, Democrat and Republican nominees, come before the United
States Congress and resolve not to let the people know what they think about
the important issues," such as a president's authority to go to war, said
Biden.
As the committee headed into its fourth day of hearings on the Alito
nomination, Biden told NBC's "Today" show that a better solution might be to
skip hearings and send nominations straight to the Senate floor for a vote.
"Just go to the Senate floor and debate the nominee's statements," the
Delaware senator said, "instead of this game."
That was once standard practice. Until 1925, Supreme Court nominees were not
expected to testify before a committee, and their nominations were sent
straight to the floor, according to the Senate Historical Office.
Biden defended Democratic senators' questions about Alito's membership in a
university group, Concerned Alumni of Princeton, known for its opposition to
opening the school to women and bringing in more minorities. Alito's wife,
Martha-Ann Bomgardner, was moved to tears during the hearing Wednesday because
of questions concerning whether her husband held any bias against women or
minorities.
"I take him at his word that he didn't know what the group stood for, but
I'm required to ask him," Biden said. He said membership in the group raised
questions about "how sensitive he is to the plight of women."
|