Bush's Drug Videos Broke Law,
Accountability Office Decide
The New York Times
By JOHN FILES
Published: January 7, 2005
WASHINGTON, Jan. 6 - The Government Accountability Office, an
investigative arm of Congress, said on Thursday that the Bush
administration violated federal law by producing and distributing
television news segments about the effects of drug use among
young people.
The accountability office said the videos "constitute covert
propaganda" because the government was not identified as the
source of the materials, which were distributed by the Office of
National Drug Control Policy. They were broadcast by nearly 300
television stations and reached 22 million households, the office
said.
The accountability office does not have law enforcement
powers, but its decisions on federal spending are usually
considered authoritative.
In May the office found that the Bush administration had
violated the same law by producing television news segments that
portrayed the new Medicare law as a boon to the elderly.
The accountability office was not critical of the content of
the video segments from the White House drug office, but found
that the format - a made-for-television "story package" -
violated the prohibition on using taxpayer money for
propaganda.
Representative Henry A. Waxman of California, the senior
Democrat on the Government Reform Committee, who requested the
review, said the use of the mock news segments broke "a
fundamental principle of open government."
A spokesman for the drug policy office said the review's
conclusions made a "mountain out of a molehill."
The spokesman, Tom Riley, noted that Congress had authorized
the drug policy office to fashion antidrug messages in motion
pictures and television programming and on the Internet. His
office stopped distributing the antidrug videos after the G.A.O.
report on the Medicare segments, Mr. Riley said, and never acted
unlawfully.
The drug policy office told investigators that it would have
been difficult for "a reasonable broadcaster" to mistake the
videos for independent news reports.
But the G.A.O. said the drug policy office "made it impossible
for the targeted viewing audience to ascertain that these stories
were produced by the government."
Federal law prohibits the use of federal money for "publicity
or propaganda purposes" not authorized by Congress. The
accountability office has found that federal agencies violated
this restriction when they distributed editorials and newspaper
articles written by government officials without identifying
them.
The accountability office said the administration's misuse of
federal money "also constitutes a violation of the Antideficiency
Act," which prohibits spending in excess of appropriations.
|