Major religions not
convinced
Zogby.com
2/16/2003)
- By Renee K. Gadoua , The Post Standard (Syracuse)
Possible Iraq war polarizes faiths
Church members don't always back leaders' positions,
however
In the last two weeks, leaders of the Roman Catholic, United
Methodist and Episcopal churches have renewed attempts to sway
President George Bush from his campaign for a unilateral military
attack on Iraq, while other religious leaders continue to support
Bush. "Listen to the voice of hundreds of thousands of Americans
and citizens of other countries who demonstrate for peace and ask
your utmost restraint," Bishop Sharon Brown, president of the
House of Bishops of the United Methodist Church - to which both
President Bush and Vice President Cheney belong - wrote to
Bush.
"Bush isn't going to pay any attention to that," said William
Barnett, a LeMoyne College religious studies professor.
That's not unusual, he said.
"Most presidents have probably made a pretty cold, political
calculation and are not influenced by the voices of the religious
leadership," he said. "Other political officeholders, like
Kennedy and Mario Cuomo, did not heed the leaders of their faith
on certain issues."
While it's unclear whether any religious leaders are
influencing Bush, his position is most in line with that of
evangelical leaders, Barnett said. Defense of one's country
Support for Bush remains consistent from national evangelical
leaders, such as Richard Land, president of the Southern Baptist
Convention's Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission.
Luis Palau, the Portland, Ore.-based international evangelist
who was in Syracuse in July for a Christian festival, recently
expressed his support.
"The feeling, broadly speaking, among Christians who take the
Bible seriously is that we are sacrificing our own men and women
for the sake of the oppressed and for greater peace around the
world," Palau said. "This war is just."
A recent survey by the American Jewish Committee found that 59
percent of American Jews approve of a U.S. military strike to
remove Saddam Hussein. That support, some experts say, reflects
concern about how war in Iraq will affect Israel.
Although Jewish organizations have taken different stands on
the issue, the majority of Jews seem to support war with Iraq,
said Rabbi Sheldon Ezring of Temple Society of Concord, a Reform
synagogue in Syracuse.
"There is no doubt that under certain conditions, this war can
be justified," he said. "If we are truly going to war to protect
the world from weapons of mass destruction, then it's imperative
to take such ability to cause chaos out of the hands of a leader
like Hussein."
According to Jewish tradition, war can be justified when it is
in defense of your country, Ezring said.
"If we are going to war because we are trying to remove
weapons of mass destruction from a perpetrator of evil on his own
people and his neighbors and a probable cause of terrorist
attacks on our nation, then in my opinion, the war is justified
and righteous," he said. "If we are going to war because of oil,
or because of the president's desire to seek revenge for the
assassination attempt on his father, then we should not be going
to war."
It may seem inconsistent for clergy to justify war, Ezring
said.
"Religious leaders have an obligation to pursue peace," he
said. "Sometimes the pursuit of peace, sadly, comes from
conflict." Faith opposition mounts
Mainline church leaders are continuing to challenge Bush.
Nationally and locally, pastors are sermonizing about the
morality of war. Religious leaders, including Christian and
Muslim clergy, are encouraging congregants to participate in
protests, sign petitions and write their elected officials.
Members of St. Andrew the Apostle Catholic Church recently
polled its congregation about placing an antiwar sign outside the
church.
The Central New York Labor-Religion Coalition passed a
resolution opposing war with Iraq.
Members of the First Unitarian Universalist Society of
Syracuse last week adopted a statement, supported by 96 percent
of the congregation, that opposes U.S. military action against
Iraq.
Students at LeMoyne College, the region's only Catholic
college, will hold a workshop Tuesday to discuss declaring the
college a peace campus.
"Positions are beginning to harden," Barnett said. "Those
traditions that tend to look at just-war tradition are those
people who are speaking out against possible war. Those
traditions that tend not to adopt just-war criteria are those
that tend to favor the administration's policy."
The nation's Roman Catholic bishops, for example, declared in
a September letter to Bush that war with Iraq cannot be morally
justified. They relied on the centuries-old concept of just war,
the conditions under which a war may be acceptable.
"The serious questions and concerns that we raised at that
time remain valid and useful as Catholics and others reflect on
the morality of a possible war with Iraq," Bishop John H. Ricard
of Pensacola-Tallahassee, Fla., chairman of the bishops'
international policy committee, said in a Feb. 7 letter to
bishops that updates Roman Catholic leaders' position.
Pope John Paul II opposes a pre-emptive war with Iraq, and
last week he sent a Vatican envoy to Baghdad on a peace
mission.
Roman Catholic leaders reflect the position of many other
Christian leaders.
The country's nine leading Eastern Orthodox bishops last week
urged government leaders to "seek a peaceful resolution to the
present challenge to the security and happiness of all
humankind."
A delegation of American church leaders organized by the
National Council of Churches met with French officials in Paris
last week as part of a European tour aimed at consolidating
international religious opposition to war.
A bishop in the United Methodist Church appears in a 30-second
commercial that says a U.S. attack on Iraq would "violate God's
law."
Presiding Bishop Frank Griswold of the Episcopal Church sent a
letter to the president in which he urged Bush "to exhaust all
diplomatic and multilateral initiatives as the alternative to
waging war." Dissension in the ranks
Strong statements from denominational leaders do not
necessarily mean agreement in the pews.
For example, Southern Baptist leaders have supported Bush, but
the convention has not taken a stand.
And a December poll by LeMoyne College/Zogby International
found that 66 percent of American Catholics say U.S. war with
Iraq is justified.
"I'm finding there is some diversity," the Rev. Marilyn
Baissa, pastor of Sauquoit Valley United Methodist Church
said.
"Very early and pretty consistently, I've heard pretty strong
voices against the war in my congregation," she said. "Of course,
there are also some who support the president and think there are
good reasons to go to war."
The Rev. Robert C. Ayres, a retired Episcopal priest who lives
in Cazenovia, considers the antiwar sentiment of local and
national Episcopal leaders misguided.
"Clerical leaders are naive about politics," the 75-year old
former Naval Reserve chaplain said. "Politics is the art of the
possible, not the art of the ideal."
He does not believe the majority of members of the American
Episcopal Church agree with their denominational leader's
stance.
"My experience is most people at the parish level are pretty
middle-of-the-road," he said.
But the debate is healthy, he said.
"Even as a Conservative, I have a certain respect for people
who stick their necks out," he said.
Even those who say war with Iraq is justified agree it would
have terrible effects, including the death of civilians.
"My prayer is that Saddam Hussein's neighbors talk him into
giving up power, or he opens the country up for total inspections
and reveals anything that may have been hidden so we can stop the
unnecessary loss of life that this war will bring about," Ezring
said.
Ayres agreed.
"I will pray that God will forgive those who made war
inevitable, and I shall certainly pray for those who are
innocent," he said. "I'll also pray for all those splendid young
people in our armed forces."
(2/16/2003)
- By Renee K. Gadoua , The Post Standard (Syracuse)
Copyright 2003 by Zogby International.
|