John Sachs: Leave or sniper
will take you out
DesMoines Register
Original title: Campaign event security spurs arrests,
removals
By LYNN CAMPBELL
REGISTER STAFF WRITER
October 16, 2004
Tight security and screening at President Bush's campaign
events in Iowa has led to at least five arrests, frightened one
teenager, and caused several other people to be turned away when
they failed to voice support for the president.
While some were protesters, others were escorted out of events
or told to leave because they were wearing buttons or T-shirts
for Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry.
"It appears that the people wanting to control the visual
images and the whole tone of these events have become so
overwhelming," said Ben Stone, executive director of the Iowa
Civil Liberties Union. "As a result of this obsession with
control, there's been this increased use of screening and
eliminating people."
The Kerry campaign has also held Iowa events that have been
closed to the public. However, reports in Iowa and across the
nation indicate that security at Kerry events is less strict. The
Des Moines Register could not find any examples of detractors
being arrested or kept out of Kerry events, and Republicans
declined to provide any examples.
Bush campaign spokesman Dan Ronayne explained that because
there's only so much space at each event, volunteers helping to
re-elect Bush are given priority at Bush campaign events over
those intending to disrupt.
"If someone were to be coming up wearing a 'John Kerry for
President' T-shirt, that is probably someone who has left the
undecided column," Ronayne said.
One of the latest incidents came when John Sachs, 18, a
Johnston High School senior and Democrat, went to see Bush in
Clive last week. Sachs got a ticket to the event from school and
wanted to ask the president about whether there would be a draft,
about the war in Iraq, Social Security and Medicare.
But when he got there, a campaign staffer pulled him aside and
made him remove his button that said, "Bush-Cheney '04: Leave No
Billionaire Behind." The staffer quizzed him about whether he was
a Bush supporter, asked him why he was there and what questions
he would be asking the president.
"Then he came back and said, 'If you protest, it won't be me
taking you out. It will be a sniper,' " Sachs said. "He said it
in such a serious tone it scared the crap out of me."
Sachs stayed at the event, but he was escorted to a section of
the 7 Flags Events Center where he was surrounded by Secret
Service and told he couldn't ask questions. "I was just in a
state of fear," he said. "I was looking at the ceiling and I
didn't know what to expect, I was so scared."
Ronayne said he wasn't aware of what happened to Sachs and
declined to comment further. "To the best of my knowledge, no
one's lives have been threatened at an event," he said.
Sachs' situation is the latest in a string of stories in which
Iowans attending Bush campaign events said they've been made to
feel unwelcome.
Other incidents include five protesters arrested outside an
event in Cedar Rapids; black and Hispanic students frisked in
Davenport; and two people denied admission in Dubuque because
they either didn't support Bush or were affiliated with someone
who didn't.
Iowa's stories are similar to those being told around the
country. According to media reports, Missouri students were in
tears after they were removed from a Bush rally because they were
wearing Kerry buttons. Others in Minnesota and Wisconsin were
asked to leave Bush rallies because they had Kerry T-shirts or
stickers.
Thursday night, police wearing riot gear fired pepperballs at
protesters gathered at a hotel in Jacksonville, Ore., where Bush
was scheduled to eat and sleep after a campaign speech. No one
was injured, but two were arrested on charges of failure to
disperse. Participants questioned the police intervention because
they said they weren't violent or disrupting traffic.
"If either campaign keeps people from attending who want to
attend, if they're not the right party or whatever, then it's
questionable about how democratic the whole process is," said Pat
Jensen of Iowa City, president of the Iowa League of Women
Voters. "It's hard to encourage people to take part in the
process if the campaigns make it difficult to do so."
Stone, of the Iowa Civil Liberties Union, said people don't
have a right to disrupt campaign events and can be removed if
they start heckling. However, he said peacefully holding a sign
or wearing a button is different. "Disruption is one thing,
expression is another, and I think that line is being crossed,"
he said.
Those attending an August campaign event for Vice President
Dick Cheney in New Mexico were asked to sign a loyalty oath,
pledging their endorsement for Bush's re-election, before they
received tickets to the event.
That spurred Kerry to joke regularly about the situation at
campaign stops in Iowa and across America. "I want to just make
certain that nobody here had to sign a loyalty oath to get in,
right?" Kerry asked during a stop in Tipton last week. "This is a
genuine open audience of Iowans, right?"
Ronayne said no such loyalty oaths are required by those
attending Bush events in Iowa. "The only paper that is
distributed at these events for people to sign entirely at their
own discretion is a volunteer form," he said.
Kerry campaign spokesman Colin Van Ostern said the Kerry
campaign encourages people from all political parties to attend
events, especially undecided voters. No loyalty oaths are
required. Because Kerry has been visiting Iowa since before the
January caucuses, "he is very comfortable in an environment that
is more unpredictable," Van Ostern said.
Thursday's rally at the Iowa State Fairgrounds featuring
Kerry, Edwards and their wives was free and open to the public,
as was Edwards' visit to Newton on Monday. Those wishing to
attend had to acquire tickets from the campaign. People said they
only had to provide their name, address and phone number to get
tickets, which also were available over the Internet.
The Bush campaign was asked to cite any instances where
Republicans or others were denied access to Kerry events in Iowa,
but declined to provide any examples. The Secret Service media
office did not return a call seeking an explanation of policies
on security at presidential campaign events.
Lynn Karwoski, 50, a Davenport Republican who has actively
volunteered for President Bush's re-election campaign, said she
hasn't had any problems getting access to Bush's campaign events
this year.
In August, she personally greeted Bush in a visit to
Davenport. She was then given 10 tickets to a town hall meeting
with Cheney, and was even allowed to ask him a question about gay
marriage without anyone screening her question.
"Access to the inner circle is available to those who have
worked hard in and for the party," Karwoski said. "For me, I've
been honored with the ability to go because of my
involvement."
|