British paper: Bush wanted to bomb Al
Jazeera
The Christian Science Monito
Tom Regan
November 23, 2005
A leaked memo in Britain has once again caused an uproar. This time, the
British government has acted to prevent any further publication.
The Times of London reports that the attorney general of Britain has warned
British papers that they will be prosecuted under the Official Secrets Act if
they publish details of a conversation between Tony Blair and George Bush in
which Mr. Bush is alleged to have suggested bombing Al Jazeera, the Arab
satellite TV channel based in Qatar.
Lord Goldsmith, the Attorney-General, informed ... editors including that of
The Times that "publication of a document that has been unlawfully
disclosed by a Crown servant could be in breach of Section 5 of the Official
Secrets Act.'
The Guardian reports that this is the first time the British government has
threatened to use the Official Secrets Act to prevent publication of the
details of a leaked document. "Though it has obtained court injunctions against
newspapers, the government has never prosecuted editors for publishing the
contents of leaked documents, including highly sensitive ones about the run-up
to the invasion of Iraq."
On Tuesday, the British paper the Daily Mirror published the details of a
government memo, marked Top Secret, that recorded a conversation between Bush
and Mr. Blair that took place in the White House last April 16. The Daily
Mirror's editor said he informed Downing Street that he was going to print
details of the memo, but was not told at the time to stop. That order did not
come until the day after the first story appeared in the paper.
The Evening Standard reports that the unnamed sources who leaked the memo to
the Mirror say it records "Bush suggesting that he might order the bombing of
Al-Jazeera's studios in Qatar."
And it allegedly details how Blair argued against an attack on the station's
buildings in the business district of Doha, the capital city of Qatar, which is
a key ally of the West in the Persian Gulf.
Al-Jazeera had sparked the anger of the US administration by broadcasting
video messages from Al Qaeda head Osama bin Laden and leaders of the insurgency
in Iraq, as well as showing footage of the bodies of US servicemen and Iraqi
civilians killed in fighting.
The Associated Press reports that the two unnamed sources cited by the
Mirror story had different impressions of Bush's alleged remarks.
One source, said to be in the government, was quoted as saying that the
alleged threat was "humorous, not serious,' but the newspaper
quoted another source as saying that "Bush was deadly serious, as was
Blair.'
BBC world affairs correspondent Paul Reynolds also believes that Bush's
comments were in jest.
"An attack on al-Jazeera would also have been an attack on Qatar, where the
US military has its Middle East headquarters. So the possibility has to be
considered that Bush was in fact making some kind of joke and that this was not
a serious proposition."
The Blair government did not deny the report, citing legal action against
two people believed to have leaked the memo and saying it never comments on
leaked documents. AP reports that David Keogh, a Cabinet Office civil servant,
and Leo O'Connor, who worked as a researcher in the office of Tony Clarke, a
former member of Parliament, would appear in court next week to face charges
under the Official Secrets Act in relation to the memo.
Mr. Clarke returned the five-page transcript to Blair's office.
The Washington Post, however, said that White House spokesman Scott
McClellan told the Associated Press in an e-mail, "We are not interested in
dignifying something so outlandish and inconceivable with a response." The Post
also quotes a senior diplomat in Washington who said the Bush remark as
recounted in the newspaper "sounds like one of the president's one-liners that
is meant as a joke." But, the diplomat said, "it was foolish for someone to
write it down, and now it will be a story for days."
The Post also reports:
A former senior U.S. intelligence official said that it was clear the White
House saw al-Jazeera as a problem, but that although the CIA's clandestine
service came up with plans to counteract it, such as planting people on its
staff, it never received permission to proceed. "Bombing in Qatar was never
contemplated," the former official said.
For its part, Al Jazeera released a statement Tuesday night saying that it
was trying to verify the Mirror's story about the memo, and it called on
Blair's office to "clear up the issue."
"If the report is correct, then this would be both shocking and worrisome
not only to al-Jazeera but to media organizations across the world," the
statement said. "It would cast serious doubts in regard to the US
administration's version of previous incidents involving Al Jazeera's
journalists and offices."
In April 2003, an Al Jazeera journalist died when its Baghdad office was
struck during a US bombing campaign. In November 2001, Al Jazeera's office in
Kabul, Afghanistan, was destroyed by a US missile, although no staff were in
the office at the time. US officials said they believed the target was a
"terrorist" site and did not know it was Al Jazeera's office.
The US government has said each of the above incidents was unintentional.
The Evening Standard reports that former defense minister Peter Kilfoyle
– a leading Labour opponent of the Iraq war – called for the leaked
document to be made public.
"I believe that Downing Street ought to publish this memo in the interests
of transparency, given that much of the detail appears to be in the public
domain," he told the Press Association.
"I think they ought to clarify what exactly happened on this occasion. If it
was the case that President Bush wanted to bomb al-Jazeera in what is after all
a friendly country, it speaks volumes and it raises questions about subsequent
attacks that took place on the press that wasn't embedded with coalition
forces."
CNN reports that during the 1999 air campaign over Kosovo, "US warplanes
targeted Yugoslavia's state television network. NATO officials argued it was a
legitimate target as the propaganda arm of the Yugoslav government." The
Chinese embassy in Belgrade was also hit during the same air campaign, which
killed three Chinese journalists. NATO later said the bombing was due to faulty
intelligence given to it by allies.
|