"Dedicated to exposing the lies and impeachable offenses of George W. Bush"



Index
Murtha on Iraq: 'There's Not Only No Progress, It's Worse Than It Was Prewar'
Think Progress
May 22, 2006

This morning, Jack Murtha appeared on CBS' The Early Show to talk about the Iraq war. Murtha offered a sobering assessment:

[T]here's not only no progress, it's worse than it was prewar. this thing has been mishandled so badly. The American people needed to hear. we're spending $450 billion on this war by the end of the year, $9 billion a month, and so we need to change course.

The facts appear to back Murtha up. Here's a summary of key indicators, drawn from the Brookings Institute's Iraq Index, using the most recent data available:

Pre-War Levels Now
Crude oil production 2.5 million barrels 2.14 million barrels [Apr. 2006]
Electricity 3,958 Megawatts 3,600 Megawatts [Apr. 2006]
People with access to potable water 12.9 million 8.25 million [Nov. 2005]
People with access to sewer system 6 million 5 million [Nov. 2005]

Full transcript:

CHEN: Congressman Murtha, your act of courage would be last fall when you spoke out against the war, after voting for it. Was that a difficult decision for you?

MURTHA: Well, they were irresponsive. And the thing that worried me, the troops – they went in with inadequate forces and inadequate equipment. Then in addition to that the army down the road was broken as far as I could see. And yet all the things they said were illusion. They said how much better it was getting and every progress report I saw was mischaracterized, misrepresented. So I felt an obligation to speak out in order to try to turn this thing around. The military won a victory. It was time to get out. As a matter of fact, these guys have done a marvelous job. The troops, you couldn't ask for any more. But they're caught in the middle of a civil war. I got a lot of criticism. I got lot a lot of people initially — as matter of fact — the war — over 50% of the people supported when I spoke out. And of course now it's changed considerably. Because i think they wanted to hear exactly what has happened. Exactly whether there's progress. And I said there's not only no progress, it's worse than it was prewar. This thing has been mishandled so badly. The American people needed to hear. We're spending $450 billion on this war by the end of the year, $9 billion a month, and so we need to change course.

Original Text

Commentary: