Chertoff Says He Is Responsible for Katrina
Failures
Bloomberg
February 15, 2006
Feb. 15 (Bloomberg) -- U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff
told a Senate panel today that he is responsible for the federal government's
failures in responding to Hurricane Katrina and he promised to "fix what's
wrong" with his department before the next hurricane season begins.
Chertoff, who was in his job six months when Katrina struck Aug. 29, said he
answers for the performance of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which
his department oversees, and also has the "responsibility to fix what's
wrong."
Chertoff called Katrina a storm of "unprecedented magnitude" and "one of the
most difficult and traumatic experiences of my life." He said the department
must work to improve its communications, particularly between FEMA and the
department, and better track movement of recovery supplies.
"I was astonished to see that we don't have the capabilities most 21st
century corporations have," he said.
Senators were uniformly critical of the Homeland Security Department's
response to the storm, and most said Chertoff should have done more in its
aftermath to ease the suffering of Americans who lacked basic necessities.
Still, none went so far as Senate Democratic Leader Harry Reid of Nevada, who
said early last month that Chertoff should step down.
Thomas Mann, a political analyst at the Brookings Institution in Washington,
said Chertoff's job is safe.
President George W. Bush "likens forced resignations to an admission of
culpability on his part," Mann said. The president probably has gone as far as
he's willing with the resignation of FEMA's former director, Michael Brown,
Mann said.
`Had to Replace Brown'
Chertoff today told the Senate panel he realized days after Katrina struck
that Brown should be replaced "at least in Louisiana."
Brown, in testimony before the panel on Friday, blamed Chertoff for FEMA's
problems in responding to the storm and said he thought conversations with
Chertoff during the storm response were "wasting his time."
Chertoff today said Brown's decision to bypass his superiors at the
Department of Homeland Security was "astonishing." He added: "If I had known
then what I know now about Mr. Brown's agenda, I would done something
different."
Minnesota Republican Norm Coleman said Brown should have been replaced.
"Somebody didn't tell the president he's got a FEMA director that is in way
over his head," Coleman said. "This was the perfect storm of poor
leadership."
Reviews Ending
Congressional review of the government's response to Katrina is winding
down. The Senate panel has held more than 20 hearings and may issue its report
next month. A special House committee released its report today. The
administration's review is expected later this month.
Katrina, one of the deadliest U.S. disasters on record, killed about 1,200
people. The Bush administration to date has sought $105 billion for repairs and
reconstruction.
Katrina forced 770,000 out of their homes, the greatest displacement since
the Dust Bowl migration of the 1930s, Chertoff said today. The storm destroyed
or made uninhabitable 300,000 homes, he said.
Susan Collins, a Maine Republican who chairs the Senate panel, told Chertoff
his department's response was a "failure," "plagued by indecision and delay."
Its inability to prepare for a storm with days of warning bodes ill for its
ability to prepare for unexpected terrorist attacks, she said.
"The federal department that was supposed to lead, direct and coordinate the
federal response to Katrina, was time and again late, uncertain and
ineffective," she said. "The list of critical tasks done either late or not at
all is staggering."
House Criticism
The House committee report faults Chertoff for not declaring the hurricane
an incident of national significance when the National Weather Service forecast
its severity two days before it hit. That designation would have triggered a
plan to name an experienced federal leader to prepare for and respond to the
storm.
Chertoff also waited too long to convene a board of experienced advisers
even though White House officials pressured Matthew Broderick, the Homeland
Security Department's director of operations coordination, to do so, the report
says.
`Aware of Risk'
Chertoff defended some of the department's actions before the storm,
emphasizing that a federal emergency was declared in Louisiana ahead of
Katrina, one of the few times that had ever been done before a hurricane's
landfall.
"We were acutely aware of Katrina and the risk it posed," he said.
The Senate panel opened hearings on Katrina in September and Chertoff's
appearance before it today was his first. Earlier witnesses have testified to
government failures in responding to the storm and in its aftermath.
Collins has said the panel's report will recommend the creation of emergency
operation teams made up of personnel from the Defense, Homeland Security Health
and Human Services and other departments who would focus on specific regions of
the country.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Jeff Bliss in Washington at jbliss@bloomberg.net
Nicholas Johnston in Washington at njohnston3@bloomberg.net.
|